Supplements: what works and what’s useless
6 min readUpdated on 31 October 2026
Supplements replace neither training, nor meals, nor sleep. A few have well-established effects; many others are mostly marketing. Here is the sorting, based on the International Olympic Committee (IOC) consensus and the positions of the International Society of Sports Nutrition (ISSN).
What works
These products have proven effects in healthy adults:
- whey (milk protein powder): handy to reach your protein target, but no more effective than the same amount of protein from meals. Count 20 to 30 g per serving;
- creatine monohydrate: 3 to 5 g a day for a little more strength and muscle in short, intense efforts;
- caffeine: 3 to 6 mg per kilo about an hour before exercise improves performance, but disrupts sleep if the session is late. A cup of coffee provides about 80 to 100 mg.
Useful only if you are short
Some supplements only help if your diet does not cover your needs:
- vitamin D, especially in winter: the recommended intake in Switzerland is 15 µg (600 IU) a day for adults, 20 µg (800 IU) from age 60;
- vitamin B12, essential on a vegan diet;
- omega-3 (fish or algae oil), if you never eat oily fish;
- iron, only if a blood test confirms a deficiency: in large amounts it is toxic.
What’s (nearly) useless
These products sell very well, but studies show no useful effect for most people:
- “testosterone boosters” (tribulus, fenugreek, maca…): no proven effect on testosterone or muscle in healthy men;
- BCAAs: pointless if you eat enough protein, which the programme already plans;
- “fat burners”: at best the effect of their caffeine, at worst stimulants that are risky for the heart;
- “detox” cures: your liver and kidneys already do that.
The real risk: contaminated products
Supplements are barely checked before they are sold. Some contain undeclared substances: stimulants, hormones or doping agents. The risk is highest for testosterone boosters, fat burners and “pre-workout” products.
Swiss Sport Integrity (formerly Antidoping Switzerland) strongly advises against importing supplements or ordering them online, and recommends certified products from reliable Swiss manufacturers. The tested products of the Kölner Liste (Cologne List) reduce the risk further, without removing it.
Anabolic steroids, SARMs and hormones are dangerous for the heart, the liver and your hormone balance, and banned in competition. Don’t take them.
Ask a doctor
Before taking a supplement, talk to a doctor or pharmacist if you:
- are under 18;
- are pregnant or breastfeeding;
- have a kidney, liver or heart condition;
- are on medication.
And in Nutrifik?
The programme works without any supplement: meals cover your protein. If you already use whey, you can say so in the assessment: recipes with whey can then complete your days. Nutrifik sells no products and recommends no brand.
Sources
- Maughan et al. (2018), IOC consensus statement on dietary supplements
- Kerksick et al. (2018), ISSN review of sports nutrition and supplements
- Guest et al. (2021), ISSN position stand on caffeine
- Clemesha et al. (2020), testosterone boosters versus the evidence
- Swiss Society for Nutrition (2026), vitamin D
- Swiss Sport Integrity, anti-doping fact sheet
- Cologne List, advice for athletes
General information written by Nutrifik from these sources. It does not replace the advice of a doctor or dietitian, especially in case of illness, pregnancy or treatment.
These recipes, in the right amounts for you
Take the free assessment: Nutrifik calculates your needs and gives you 3 months of meals with these recipes, portions matched to your goal, your workouts and your shopping lists.
Take my free assessmentRead next
- How much protein per day? Targets for your goal
- Lose fat without losing muscle: the 5 rules that matter
- Eating healthily on a small budget in Switzerland
- Starting strength training at home: where to begin
- Creatine: what it does, how much, is it safe?
- Sleep and recovery: the forgotten pillar of results
- 10 easy (and cheap) protein snacks
- Starting running from scratch
- Healthy shopping list in Switzerland: what to buy and what it costs